Download A Strange Likeness: Becoming Red and White in by Nancy Shoemaker PDF

By Nancy Shoemaker

The connection among American Indians and Europeans on America's frontiers is usually characterised as a sequence of cultural conflicts and misunderstandings according to an unlimited gulf of distinction. Nancy Shoemaker turns this idea on its head, exhibiting that Indians and Europeans shared universal ideals approximately their so much primary realities--land as nationwide territory, executive, record-keeping, foreign alliances, gender, and the human physique. earlier than they even met, Europeans and Indians shared perceptions of a panorama marked by way of mountains and rivers, a actual international within which the sunlight rose and set on a daily basis, and a human physique with its personal particular form. additionally they shared of their skill to make feel of all of it and to invent new, summary principles in keeping with the tangible and visual reviews of lifestyle. concentrating on jap North the United States up in the course of the finish of the Seven Years struggle, Shoemaker heavily reads incidents, letters, and recorded speeches from the Iroquois and Creek confederacies, the Cherokee country, and different local teams along British and French assets, paying specific recognition to the language utilized in cross-cultural dialog. satirically, the extra American Indians and Europeans got here to grasp one another, the extra they got here to determine one another as various. by way of the top of the 18th century, Shoemaker argues, they deserted an preliminary willingness to acknowledge in one another a typical humanity and as a substitute constructed new principles rooted within the conviction that, through customized and maybe even by way of nature, local americans and Europeans have been peoples essentially at odds. In her research, Shoemaker unearths the 18th century roots of tolerating stereotypes Indians built approximately Europeans, in addition to stereotypes Europeans created approximately Indians. This robust and eloquent interpretation questions long-standing assumptions, revealing the unusual likenesses one of the population of colonial North the United States.

Show description

Read or Download A Strange Likeness: Becoming Red and White in Eighteenth-Century North America PDF

Best native american studies books

Neither Wolf Nor Dog: American Indians, Environment, and Agrarian Change

In the course of the 19th century, americans regarded to the eventual civilization and assimilation of local american citizens via a technique of removing, reservation, and directed tradition swap. guidelines for directed subsistence switch and incorporation had far-reaching social and environmental effects for local peoples and local lands.

Uncommon Defense: Indian Allies in the Black Hawk War

Within the spring of 1832, while the Indian warrior Black Hawk and one thousand fans marched into Illinois to reoccupy lands previous ceded to American settlers, the U. S. military became to rival tribes for army aid. parts of the Menominee, Dakota, Potawatomi, and Ho chew tribes willingly allied themselves with the us govt opposed to their fellow local american citizens in an unusual safeguard in their assorted pursuits.

Kahnawa:ke: Factionalism, Traditionalism, and Nationalism in a Mohawk Community (The Iroquoians and Their World)

At the present time Kahnaw? :ke (“at the rapids”) is a neighborhood of roughly seventy-two hundred Mohawks, situated at the south shore of the Saint Lawrence River close to Montreal. one of many greatest Mohawk groups, it's identified within the smooth period for its activism—a traditionalist, lively impulse with an extended historical past.

Tribal Boundaries in the Nass Watershed

This article provides the reaction of the Gitksan and Gitanyow to using the treaty strategy via the Nisga'a to extend into Gitksan and Gitanyow territory at the Nass River. It makes a contribution to the query of the way First international locations in vital British Columbia identify their rights to territory.

Extra info for A Strange Likeness: Becoming Red and White in Eighteenth-Century North America

Sample text

10 Other high-profile visits involved In­ dians from the Southeast. 1). 11 Cherokees came again in 1762, only three this time. 1 Isaac Basire engraving of the seven Cherokees who visited London in 1730 with Alexander Cuming. Courtesy of the National Anthropological Archives, Smithsonian Institution/neg. #01063–H-2. 15 From the 1710 Mohawk dele­ gation up through British victory in the Seven Years War, Indian “kings” in Europe mesmerized a gawking populace while attending the theater, travers­ ing London and Paris streets, and outfitting themselves for presentation at court.

Take for example a 1750 Moravian diary recounting the observations and conversa­ tions made on a journey from Pennsylvania to an Iroquois Confederacy coun­ cil meeting at Onondaga. The Moravian missionaries and their Cayuga guide, Hahotschaunquas, saw the landscape through different eyes. Hahotschaunquas told the history of each place. ” Fur­ ther on, they came to a forest of tall trees where there were three red-painted posts to which three Catawba prisoners had been tied. When they reached a certain mountain, Hahotschaunquas mentioned that that was where his child had been born, and as they climbed up the mountain, he pointed out a battle­ ground where the Cayugas had fought with the aforementioned ancient people.

26 The cause of the fight was a dispute over the nature of their political authority. Some of the delegation proposed murdering their speaker for having consented to a treaty promising Cherokee subjection to the king of England. They knew that not one of them could claim to be a desig­ nated leader with the right to speak for his townspeople. 28 Indians who went to Europe without public authority endangered alliances because Europeans treated them as representatives—if not as political repre­ sentatives, then as cultural icons—of their nations.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.79 of 5 – based on 23 votes